What Is The Best Yogurt Maker? 5 Top Options (2019 Edition)

Yogurt isn’t expensive or hard to find, but you can make your own custom yogurts even more inexpensively with the best yogurt maker!

Which of the yogurt makers on the market is best? These 5 stand out among all options as some of the best. Let’s take a closer look so you can make your own yogurt at home in no time.

**Below, you'll find more detailed reriews, but you can click links above to see current prices and read customer's reviews on Amazon


Choosing The Best Yogurt Maker

If you’ve never tried using a yogurt maker before, you may not know what features to be looking for. Does size matter most, or is there something else?

Thankfully for you, I’ve already done a lot of research about yogurt makers for you! The best yogurt maker can be chosen easily if you consider the following points before making any purchases. Let’s get started with my short yogurt maker buyer’s guide.

Type Of Yogurt Maker

Via Amazon.com

There are electric and non-electric yogurt makers on the market. These two types of yogurt makers differ in many ways, so you will have to choose which one fits your particular wants and needs.

Non-electric yogurt makers use hot water to warm the milk and help it ferment. This type of yogurt maker uses the power of insulation to keep the temperature at the right degree throughout the process. Electric yogurt makers have timers and precise temperature control that keep the yogurt making process running smoothly.

Most first-time yogurt makers will want to get a yogurt maker that is electric. These are, generally speaker, more successful in terms of yogurt production thanks to their precise controls.


Via Amazon.com

The next thing you will want to consider while choosing a yogurt maker is how much yogurt it can make at one time. Different yogurts have different capacities, and only you can be sure about how much you want to make.

There are yogurt makers that make one big tub of yogurt and others that make the yogurt in smaller, serving-sized portions. Depending on how you plan to use and enjoy your yogurt, you will probably prefer one of these options over the other.

I’ve found that the yogurt makers that create smaller, serving-sized portions of yogurt are the most convenient type of yogurt maker. You can use as much yogurt as you need and even take it with you on the go as a snack easily thanks to this maker.

Ease Of Use

Via Amazon.com

While getting a very cool looking kitchen appliance is always fun, the most important thing about yogurt makers is definitely not design.

Rather than looking for slick and stylish, look for functional and simple!

You won’t be able to make any yogurt if you can’t understand your yogurt maker, so it is a good idea to focus on functionality.

Consider how easy the yogurt maker is to use.

Are there are a lot of confusing instructions, or are they easy to understand? Is the design of the yogurt maker user-friendly? Focus on these things to choose a yogurt maker that you will actually want to use.

Precise Temperature Controls

Via Amazon.com

It’s very important to have good temperature control while making your own yogurt. The fermentation process will not work properly if the right temperatures are not maintained, so looking for a yogurt maker with precise temperature controls is very important.

Holding temperatures and fermentation time is critical while making yogurt. Yogurt has live bacteria in it, and without the right temperature range, the yogurt will not develop properly.

There are a different temperature ranges needed for different yogurt options, but you will want to be sure that the maker has good control over temperature so that the yogurt comes out thick and sharp.

Timing Controls

Via elizabethwendland.com

As mentioned in the temperature section above, timing is also very important while making yogurt. Just like when you make bread, there is a period of downtime needed while making yogurt, and yogurt makers with good timers will be the most successful.

The time needed for fermentation can range from 5 to 8 hours. The best yogurt maker will have a timer and auto-shutoff features that will ensure your yogurt comes out just right. Meticulous timing is necessary for great yogurt!

Durability & Warranty

It can be very frustrating when you invest in a new kitchen appliance on to have it fail just a few days later. When buying any new appliance, you need to check durability and warranty options.

A yogurt maker will be more durable if it is made out of more high-quality parts that will not easily break or fail.

In terms of warranty, check if the yogurt maker comes standard with a full or limited warranty. This will protect you if the appliance fails in the first few months of owning it.

Other Add-ons

Via Amazon.com

While not necessary, there are a few other add-ons that may come with yogurt makers. These add-ons can be beneficial depending on your skill level or what you want to do with the yogurt maker.

Some possible add-ons include:

  • Recipe books
  • Thermometers
  • Cheese straining bag
  • Cheese making features
  • Holding warms for crepes and eggs

If any of these add-ons are included in our top 5, we have included information about that in the reviews below.

Top 5 Best Yogurt Makers of 2017

1. Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker

Via Amazon.com

The first of the top yogurt makers to consider today is the Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker. This electric yogurt maker allows you to make single servings of your favorite yogurt with ease.

This yogurt maker is very simple to use once you get the hang of it, and that’s what I like most about it. After boiling your yogurt, you simply put it into the containers and let it sit for the required number of hours. The maker keeps the yogurt warm at the right temperature so that it sets up properly.

I also love that this model comes with 7 serving-sized containers for your yogurt. This means that you can make yogurt once a week and still enjoy a serving of yogurt every day. It’s even possible to use the yogurt you make as the starter for the next week’s batch!


  • Includes 7 serving-size contains to make small batches of yogurt
  • Very simple to use
  • Reliable and durable
  • Can see the yogurt while it is fermenting


  • Does not have a timer, just a number system printed on it
  • Instructions are a bit vague

2. Epica Homemade Organic “Set and Go” Electric Yogurt Maker

Via Amazon.com

The next yogurt maker to consider is the Epica Homemade Organic “Set and Go” Electric Yogurt Maker. This electric yogurt maker takes yogurt making to the next level to make the whole process easier and more efficient.

The size of the seven small jars included with this yogurt maker is perfect for a small morning snack. They hold about 6 ounces of yogurt each, making them a great size for your family members young and old.

Another thing I love about this yogurt maker is that the yogurt it produces is a great texture and very firm. If you don’t use the right amount of milk, it may be a little bit runny. But, overall, the texture of the yogurt is perfect without having to make many adjustments. Simply follow the directions, and you’ll be good to go!


  • The lids and jars are dishwasher safe
  • Light indicates that the yogurt maker is on very easily
  • Creates yogurt with a great texture and firmness
  • Easy to understand instructions


  • The recommended amount of milk is too much; put in a little bit less for better texture
  • No timer included

3. Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker

Via Amazon.com

Another interesting choice for a yogurt maker is this Greek yogurt maker, the Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker. This maker is a non-electric model, and it might not be what you expect, but you can make great Greek yogurt using this simple device.

I love this strainer because I love Greek yogurt! While many different yogurt makers can make yogurt, not many of them can turn that yogurt into Greek yogurt. And that is exactly what this product does. This strainer gets rid of excess whey to turn regular yogurt into Greek yogurt. It does not make yogurt from scratch, but it makes delicious Greek yogurt!

Since the sides of this strainer are transparent, it’s easy to see if the straining has happened or not. If it’s done, you’ll see that there is a lot of liquid at the bottom of the strainer. That’s how you know it’s time to remove your yogurt!


  • Strains excess whey to make delicious Greek yogurt
  • Can see if the straining is complete easily
  • Strainer rinses easily if you rinse it right away
  • Takes between 4 and 8 hours to strain


  • Mesh may rip if you are not gentle enough with the strainer
  • Doesn’t make yogurt; filters yogurt into Greek yogurt

4. Euro Cuisine YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker

Via Amazon.com

The next yogurt maker worth checking out is the Euro Cuisine YMX650 Automatic Digital Yogurt Maker. This yogurt maker is digital and is a bit more advanced than some of the other options.

One of the things I love most about this machine is that it has an automatic shut-off feature. This feature allows you to set the yogurt to create and then forget about it. It will turn off the incubation settings automatically! Most yogurt makers need you to set your own timer, but this yogurt maker makes the process much easier.

Another thing that is great about this model is the design. The lids fit into an upper compartment which makes it very easy to store all of the parts while you are not using it, and it also makes the lids easy to locate when you are ready to close up the smaller containers.


  • Automatic shut-off feature15-hour timer has alarm feature
  • 3-year warranty
  • Sleek design with lid compartment


  • Bottom gets too warm sometimes
  • Timer may break over time

5. Yogourmet Electric Yogurt Maker

Via Amazon.com

The final yogurt maker I would like to introduce is the Yogourmet Electric Yogurt Maker.This yogurt maker allows you to make a large batch of yogurt at once, and that is what I like most about it! Many yogurt makers are moving to smaller batches, so it can be hard to find a large batch maker these days.

This model has a bit of a larger learning curve due to the way it is set up. You have to figure out how to control the temperature and time when you start using it, and while there are instructions, it may take a few batches to get it right.


  • Large batch yogurt maker
  • Makes very thick yogurt
  • Can use glass jars inside of the yogurt maker instead of the included plastic container if you want to


  • Develops small cracks over time that may leak
  • Has no way to control the temperature or time spent

Churn Up Some Yogurt

Via Amazon.com

Making yogurt is a surprisingly fun and easy process, especially when you have one of the best yogurt maker options helping. Yogurt makers help the process to be more successful and efficient, and who doesn’t want that?

The best yogurt maker among these options is definitely the Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker. This yogurt maker stands out because of its very simple design that is intuitive and easy to use. All you need to know is how much fat is in your milk so that you know how long to set a timer for! The incubator does the rest of the work, so you don’t have to worry about anything.


Do you have any experience using a yogurt maker at home? What kind of yogurt do you prefer to make? Share with me in the comments; I want to try all of your yogurt recipes out on my yogurt maker!

Sophia Gardner

I'm Sophia, food blogger, dog lover, homemade cooking and travel passion. I really hope you enjoy my blog, i'll do my best to share great recipes, healthy living tips and just general 'food' thoughts!

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments
%d bloggers like this: